Up the Clove Before Dark: How I’d Spend Three Christmas Nights in Hunter, NY This Year

Every December somebody in my family floats the same idea: skip the airport and spend Christmas somewhere with snow on the roofs and nowhere to be. This year I finally priced it out, and the place I keep landing on is Hunter, New York, a Catskills ski town about two and a half hours from Midtown Manhattan. It has a real mountain, a painted Main Street next door in Tannersville, and a frozen waterfall twenty minutes down the road.

I’m not the only one looking. Airbnb’s winter trends report says searches for Christmas and New Year’s stays in Hunter are up 37% over last year, the biggest jump of any small mountain town on its list. AirDNA’s holiday data shows three-night Christmas stays up about 35%. So here’s how my team and I would build a three-night Hunter Christmas, Dec. 23 to Dec. 26: the money, the drive up the clove, and the gear that keeps a short trip from going sideways.

The base of the Kaatskill Flyer chairlift at Hunter Mountain, with skiers lined up on early-season snow under a cloudy sky
Photo: CurlingMan13 / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 4.0

If You Only Read One Section

Book three nights, not two, because the cleaning fee hurts less spread over more nights. Arrive on the 23rd before dark, since Route 23A through Kaaterskill Clove is no fun on ice at 6 p.m. Put the ski lesson on Christmas Eve morning, when holiday hours start at 8:30. Save Kaaterskill Falls for Christmas morning, and bring Kahtoola MICROspikes, because the stairs to the base ice over. Keep a AstroAI 27-Inch Snow Brush and Ice Scraper and a set of AutoSock Snow Socks in the car, because rental driveways in the Catskills are steep. Leave on the 26th before 10 a.m. to beat the return wave.

Why Hunter Instead of Vermont

The appeal is distance. Stowe or Killington is a five-hour drive from New York on a good day, and on Dec. 23 there are no good days. Hunter is roughly 120 miles from Manhattan up the Thruway, and from Philadelphia it’s about three and a half hours. That’s close enough to leave after a half day of work and still see the lifts before dinner.

Tannersville bills itself as the highest village in New York. Height matters in a warm year: the valley can be rain while Main Street is white. Hunter Mountain itself is a Vail Resorts mountain with a 3,200-foot summit, a tubing park and a full ski school. Its projected opening this season is the week before Thanksgiving, so by Christmas there should be a month of snowmaking on the trails.

I wrote about the Catskills in summer back in June. Winter here is a quieter, colder trip. The farm stands are closed and the hiking crowds are gone, but the lights go up on Main Street and the ski lots fill on weekends.

The Three-Night Math

Here’s why I’d book three nights. Take a typical three-bedroom cabin near the mountain at, say, $425 a night with a $250 cleaning fee. Two nights comes to $1,100 before taxes and platform fees, or $550 a night. Three nights is $1,525, or about $508 a night. The fixed fees shrink every night you add, and the third night gives you a full day that isn’t half spent in the car.

Those are example numbers. Run your own off the final checkout screen, not the nightly rate on the listing. Taxes and fees can add a third. If you can’t get the 23rd, the 26th to 29th works too, and it’s often cheaper once Christmas is over. Hunter’s New Year’s Eve party, with a torchlight parade, groomer parade and fireworks, is Dec. 31 if you’d rather stay later.

Ask the host three things before you pay

First, is the driveway plowed, and by whom? Second, is there a lot of uphill from the road? Third, what’s the heat source, and is there backup if the power goes out? I learned the driveway lesson planning a Boone cabin weekend, and the Catskills have the same steep gravel drives.

The Drive Up the Clove

Take the Thruway to Exit 20 at Saugerties or Exit 21 at Catskill, then climb Route 23A through Kaaterskill Clove to Haines Falls, Tannersville and Hunter. It’s one of the prettiest roads in New York. It’s also narrow, with tight bends and a steep grade, and it ices fast once the sun drops. Sunset on Christmas Eve is around 4:25 p.m., so I’d plan to be through the clove by 4.

If a storm is coming, take the gentler way. Stay on Route 23 west from Catskill through Cairo to Windham, then come down Route 296 into Hunter. It adds a few minutes and loses most of the steep pitch. Also, don’t park in the 23A pull-offs to gawk at the falls. The Molly Smith lot is closed, and the Town of Hunter tickets and tows.

A snow-covered two-lane road stretching straight ahead between rows of frosted pine trees under a pale winter sky

What rides in my trunk

The AstroAI 27-Inch Snow Brush and Ice Scraper is long enough to clear an SUV roof. The AutoSock Snow Socks are the backup for a slick driveway. I covered how they compare to chains in my post on snow socks and traction laws. Cold kills weak batteries, so a NOCO Boost Plus GB40 Jump Starter lives in the side pocket. A box of HotHands Hand Warmers rides along too, for scraping windows at 7 a.m.

Night One: Main Street Before Dinner

Arrive, unload, and walk Tannersville’s Main Street while it’s still lit. The village is known for its painted storefronts in pinks, teals and purples, and from late November into early January they’re strung with holiday lights. The general store, with its ice cream sign, still does a busy trade in December.

The Tannersville General Store, a two-story building painted mauve with pink and teal trim, a covered porch and benches along Main Street
Photo: DKBALDWIN1 / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 3.0

Keep the first night simple. Pick up groceries for breakfast before the stores close early on Christmas Eve. Grab dinner on Main Street and lay out ski clothes before bed. On a three-night trip, the night you arrive mostly sets up the next day.

Christmas Eve: A Morning Lesson and an Afternoon on Tubes

Hunter’s posted hours for weekends and holidays start at 8:30 a.m. For first-timers, the resort runs group lessons for adults and kids, and a morning lesson leaves the afternoon free to practice. Read the fine print, though: standard lessons generally don’t include a lift ticket or rentals. Add discounted tickets and rentals when you book the lesson, and book all three for the same date. Holiday lessons sell out.

Two young kids in helmets and goggles practicing on short skis on a gentle groomed beginner slope

If your legs haven’t seen a mountain since last March, start now. My colleague on our health site has a four-week ski-legs plan you can do in the living room. One month of squats is cheaper than spending Christmas Day on the couch.

The small gear that makes a cold ski day bearable

Rental packages at Hunter include a helmet, but not the layers. A Smartwool Classic Thermal Merino Base Layer under your jacket does more than a heavier coat. A pair of Darn Tough Over-the-Calf Ski Socks keeps rental boots from rubbing. Bring goggles you can see through on a gray day: the Smith Squad Goggles come with a second low-light lens. Put one of the HotHands Hand Warmers in each glove before the first chair.

Rustic cabin mudroom bench with scuffed white ski boots, rolled gray wool socks, a green steel thermos, ski goggles and spiked traction cleats, a green parka and knit hat on wall hooks, snow outside the window

Wet boots ruin day two. A PEET Original Boot Dryer plugged in by the cabin door has everyone’s boots dry and warm by morning. Cabins rarely have a mudroom heater, and boots set by the woodstove crack.

After lunch, go tubing. Hunter’s tubing park sells timed sessions on weekends and holidays, and you don’t need any skill or lessons. It’s the activity the non-skiers in the family will remember.

A person in a dark jacket and knit hat riding a red and yellow snow tube over a bump on a sunny snowy hillside

Christmas Morning: Kaaterskill Falls on Ice

Christmas morning is when I’d see the falls. Kaaterskill Falls drops about 260 feet in two tiers, and in a cold December it freezes into columns of blue-white ice. Park at the Laurel House Road lot off North Lake Road. Don’t park on 23A. From the lot, it’s 0.3 mile on a wide gravel path to a viewing platform, an easy walk for most of the family.

A 19th-century stereograph card showing Kaaterskill Falls frozen into tall ice columns between dark pines

The stairs from the platform down to the base, about 0.7 mile from the lot, are another matter. Spray freezes on the stone steps early in the season, and people slip on the gravel path even in regular boots. That’s what the Kahtoola MICROspikes are for. They slip over any boot in about ten seconds and bite into ice that sneakers just slide across. Two pairs cover a family, since kids can often stay at the platform.

Holiday lots can fill by 10 a.m., so go early. A Stanley Classic Legendary Bottle full of cocoa at the platform turns the walk into a tradition. Pack a Black Diamond Spot 400 Headlamp too. The woods get dark by 4, and a short hike can run late.

The afternoon belongs to the cabin

After the falls, nobody goes anywhere. Most restaurants are closed or booked solid on Christmas Day, so plan a cabin dinner and buy the groceries on the 23rd. Bring a board game everyone can learn in ten minutes. Ticket to Ride has survived three generations at my table. If the family exchanges gifts on the trip, start a shared gift list on gifts.omnux.com before you pack. Everyone can claim gifts quietly, nobody shows up with the same scarf, and you’re not carrying extra boxes up an icy driveway.

Log cabin living room at dusk with a lit Christmas tree, brown-paper and red wrapped gifts, a train-route board game with cards and two steaming mugs on a wooden coffee table, snowy pines outside the window

Dec. 26: Out the Door Before Ten

Checkout is usually 10 or 11. I’d be loaded by 9:30. Hertz says Dec. 26 is one of its three busiest pickup days of the season, and plenty of drivers are heading south from upstate that morning. Leaving early puts you on the Thruway before the late-morning wave. If you drove up via Windham, go home the same way, because nobody needs to start a four-hour drive with a downhill 23A on fresh ice.

On the way out, run the snow brush over the car properly and check the tires. If you’re driving through the city, my Christmas market road-trip guide covers the Bryant Park market, which is open through early January, if the kids need one more stop.

What Could Go Wrong

Snow isn’t guaranteed. The Northeast had a great 2025-26 season, but a strong El Niño year can mean rain at the base and a thin cover on the upper trails. Hunter makes snow on most of its terrain, so lessons and tubing usually run even in a lean December. Check the resort’s live mountain report the week before. If the forecast turns warm, the falls, the Main Street lights and the cabin still make a good Christmas.

Power is the other risk. Catskills outages happen in ice storms, and a rental with only electric heat gets cold fast. This is where the third question to the host pays off. Pack the headlamp, keep the jump starter charged and keep the hand warmers handy.

There’s one more upside to Hunter. If you love it, you can be back in late January for a long weekend. Few Christmas trips are that easy to repeat.

My Hunter Christmas Packing List

Two and a half hours, three nights and one icy waterfall. For a lot of families on the East Coast, that’s a better Christmas than a crowded airport and a middle seat. Book the cabin this week, before the other 37% do.

Leave a Comment